I should have done this before I wrote the review below, but I tried the Maybelline gel liner out today on my top lid and I'm pleased to say that it was long lasting (I wore it for 7 hours) and didn't smudge at all :)
I think the key is less product and slowly build it up rather than just drawing a thick line straight out. You know what I mean?
I know my eyebrows need tweezing LOL and I took this when I got home which explains why I'm flushed cos I walked home :)
But yeah as you can see, the top line is still intact! Its a little light but thats only because I hardly use a lot of product when lining the top of my eyes.
So yeah, all in all. Do try out this eyeliner if you're not willing to fork out the extra money for the more bigger brand eyeliners. I'm not sure about how fast it dries up since it is pretty cheap ... but I'll let you guys know!
I'm gonna try the Dolly Wink liquid liner, once I get a hold of it >:)